Dinner

Classic Double Cheeseburgers

A double smash burger with melted American cheese and a tangy homemade burger sauce.

Classic Double Cheeseburgers — finished dish

Ingredients at a glance

4 servings
Classic Double Cheeseburgers — ingredient flat lay

25–35 min active / 25–40 min total

Tick ingredients as you gather them. Checks last while this page is open.

Method

Equipment: Heavy skillet or griddle, sturdy metal spatula, thermometer, clean plate and sauce bowl.

  1. 01

    Heat a skillet or griddle over medium-high heat.

  2. 02

    Keep beef cold and divide the 1½ lb into eight loose balls, about 3 oz each, for four double burgers. Do not knead salt into the mince.

  3. 03

    Place only as many balls as fit comfortably on the hot skillet or griddle. Immediately smash each once into a thin patty using a sturdy spatula; do not keep pressing after a crust forms.

  4. 04

    Season with salt and pepper.

  5. 05

    Cook until browned underneath and the edges release, roughly 2–3 minutes, then scrape under each patty and flip. Continue cooking to 71°C / 160°F at the center; insert a fine probe from the side if needed. Work in batches and keep cooked patties on a clean plate.

  6. 06

    Divide the four cheese slices between four of the patties. Let melt during the final cooking stage and stack each with a second fully cooked patty.

  7. 07

    Toast the cut buns briefly in a light film of rendered beef fat in the pan. If the pan contains burnt residue, wipe it out and dry-toast the buns instead. No additional butter is required.

  8. 08

    Mix mayo, mustard, grated onion, hot sauce, and Worcestershire.

  9. 09

    Assemble with sauce, lettuce, tomato, and the burger patty.

  10. 10

    Serve immediately.

Notes & keeping

Use about 20% fat ground beef for the owner’s juicy double-patty version. Make twice as many beef balls as buns.

Season the outside just before cooking and smash only at the beginning. Do not use a steak’s lower center temperature for minced beef.

Bun sizes and nutrition vary. Check the actual package rather than carrying over the original standard-bun calorie assumption.